Our Agency
We’re dedicated to serving our community with integrity, professionalism, and a touch of local charm.
Meet Our Team
Jonathan Gaudio
Agency Owner
I’ve gotten to know many local families as an insurance agent in Ohio. I enjoy being a part of the community, and building local relationships is one of the best parts of my job. I know what life is like here in Ohio – that you choose your car and your home to fit your lifestyle and your budget. I also know how important it is to do the same when it comes to insurance. I look forward to getting to know you and helping you to find the solutions that meet your needs.
Part of what I like best about my job is that I can offer customers options for a wide variety of coverage and services. You can depend on me to help you look at the big picture.
I’m committed to helping Ohio residents assess their immediate and long-term needs and choose options that will help them achieve their goals. When you want to explore options for protecting your home, personal property, or financial future, I’m available to answer your questions. If you’re already a customer, I’m ready to review your coverage so that you can make any necessary adjustments to fit your changing needs. Call me today for a free quote.
Management
Adam Agin
Chief Operating Officer
I am a resident of Zanesville, Ohio and have worked for the Gaudio Insurance Group since January 2017. I lead our agency and sales team in day to day operations to help see you feel like family with our agency. We look forward to meeting you in person, stop by our agency in Columbus, OH, Mason, OH and New Philadelphia, OH to meet our team!
Lisa Avon
Director of Service
I am a resident of New Philadelphia, Ohio and have worked for the Gaudio Insurance Group since July 2020. I lead our service team and together, we help see that customers get the top-notch service they deserve from our amazing team. Come in and meet our team in Columbus, OH, Mason, OH and New Philadelphia, OH, we look forward to getting to know you!
Joshua Stevens
Sales Manager
I am a resident of Newark, Ohio and started my insurance career representing Gaudio Insurance Group in June 2017. I began working with the Gaudio Insurance Group here in Newark in March 2018. I am licensed in Property Insurance and Casualty Insurance, as well as Life Insurance and Health insurance. I specialize in Auto Insurance, Life Insurance, Business Insurance, Home & Condo Insurance. My primary focus within the agency is bringing in new customers.
Tricia Mccullough
Sales Coach
I’m a resident here in Ohio and began working for the Gaudio Insurance Group in 2019. With over 17 years of experience in the insurance industry. I have a passion for helping customers and team. From Homeowners Insurance, Condo Insurance and Renters Insurance to Auto Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance and ATV Insurance, I am happy to help you find the best coverage for you and your family. I focus primarily on sales training and quality assurance within the agency.
I’m an avid dance mom and in my spare time, I enjoy spending time with my family and doing photography. I’ve been married for 20 years with two kids, 20 and 12.
I look forward to assisting you with your insurance needs.
Danielle Johnson
Customer Care Manager
I am a resident here in Heath Ohio, and started my insurance career representing Gaudio Insurance Group in April 2017. I began working for the Gaudio Insurance Group here in Newark Ohio in March 2019. I am licensed in Property and Casualty Insurance including car, home & condo insurance, and primarily focus on the customer service aspect of our agencies.
Jenna Nance
Quality Assurance Manager
I am a resident of Milford, Ohio and work here at the Mason office. I was introduced to insurance in 2017 and have loved servicing our clients ever since. I enjoy assisting clients with their personal coverages such as home and auto insurance and always strive to provide the best service and care that I can. Outside of the office, I enjoy spending quality time with both friends and family.
Crystal Latoski
Sales – Performance Coach
I’m a lifelong resident of Reynoldsburg / Pickerington area, where I raised my 2 sons and my dog. With the growth acquisition at Gaudio Insurance Group, I merged with the team in 2022.
Kelly Vargin
Customer Service – Coach
Sharon Dragich
Customer Service – Coach
Sales
Brooke Willhoite
Licensed Sales Producer – Lead
I recently married my husband after 11 years of being together and we have a son who is 4 years old. I am also a bonus mom to 2 boys, one of which is in the Army, and the other who is only 13. We enjoy camping and racing in our spare time. My family and I look forward to making you part of our group to help see you are protected like our family is.
Mike Egidi
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
I find joy and take pride in helping others navigate insurance. I have 12 years of Property and Casualty Insurance experience. I love taking an informatory role when helping procure insurance for those unfamiliar. I specialize in Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Landlord Insurance, Umbrella policies and Recreational Vehicle policies. My wife Diana and toddler daughter Gianna love going to petting zoo’s and enjoying Lancaster life. We also have two dogs names Juno (French Bulldog) and Bean (Boston Terrier).
Chelsa Lane
Licensed Sales Producer – Lead
In my time as a Licensed Insurance Professional, my time here at Jonathon Gaudio’s Insurance Group has by far been the most rewarding in my career. I get to do what I love the most everyday, which is helping people! My number 1 goal with customers is to help see that they understand how their insurance works, and that they have the right protection for their needs for both their Auto insurance and Home Insurance. Helping see you are covered when you need it the most, is what we do here… Are you in Good Hands?
Mark Robison
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
I am licensed in everything, but my main focus is definitely personal home and auto.
Noah Meeker
Licensed Sales Producer – Lead
Tawer Michael
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
As an Insurance Agent with 10+ years of experience and expertise I have been able to use my knowledge and exceptional customer service skills to educate and protect many families across the states from the unexpected. I look forward providing you and your family with the same service I have been known for. My goal is to protect you and your family while offering coverages like Auto, Home, Business, Boats, Motorcycles and more! Away from work I like to spend time with my family, travel, play and watch soccer. I look forward to building many more great relationships along my journey.
Mark Fausel
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
I am Mark Fausel, your personal insurance professional. I am dedicated to serve you with a passion for protecting what matters most to you, I specialize in finding insurance solutions that are tailored to fit your needs. Whether it’s safeguarding your home, securing your family’s future, or any other insurance need, I’m here to guide you through the complexities of insurance with personalized care and expertise. Let’s work together to build a comprehensive plan that gives you piece of mind and the protection you and your family deserve.
Joe Cooke
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
I have been a Licensed Agent since 2016. I am licensed in Auto and Home. I enjoy helping customers by learning about their insurance needs and educating them on what is available to fulfil those needs. I have helped thousands of customers get the peace of mind that comes with the knowledge that they are properly covered. I am a husband and a father of two young children.
Meagan Gaines
Licensed Sales Producer – Lead
Allison Causey
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
Akshat Ahluwalia
Licensed Sales Producer
Jamie Morreale
Licensed Sales Producer
Olivia Nugent
Life Specialist
My name is Olivia Nugent, and I am a licensed life and health insurance agent here with the Gaudio Insurance Group. As soon as I started my journey in insurance, I immediately knew that’s where I needed to be. My number one goal is to educate clients on their insurance needs and ensure our families are protected. I’m a huge animal person, and outside of work I enjoy cooking, spending time with family, and being outdoors!
Michael Tamarkin
Life Specialist
I have been in the life insurance business for over 10 years after a long career in retail and restaurants. I specialize in life insurance to assist families, individuals and businesses in financial security and family protection. Whether interested in term coverage or permanent, we can find a solution to meet your needs. I reside in Columbus, Ohio with my wife and have 3 grown children. I am an avid cyclist, snow skier and scuba diver. I also enjoy traveling.
Tyler Jones
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
Elizabeth Riggs
Licensed Sales Producer
Ashley Dean
Licensed Sales Producer
As your local insurance agent, I am here to help you identify the insurance coverage that best fits your needs. This process is straight forward and personalized to help make the best choices about your insurance. I have the knowledge and experience to help you better understand your coverage options and properly protect your assets!
Brad Shaver
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
I am licensed in Auto, Home, Life and Health. My experience includes working as a National Account Manager for Select Quote Insurance Services based out of Kansas City, Mo. specializing in Life Insurance. I then took a position working with State Farm to consult with clients on a broader scale with Auto, Home and Life to help them navigate their need for protection. After becoming very familiar with the competitive landscape of insurance companies.
Amy Tomina
Licensed Sales Producer – Lead
Christopher Clark
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
I have been a licensed insurance advisor for over 6 years specializing in auto & home, renters, umbrella, motorcycle, boat and recreational vehicles. I try to offer a consultative approach so that we get you properly protected within your budget and also ensure that you understand your coverage options. I enjoy playing/watching sports and spending time with my family.
Kyle Dustin
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
My name is Kyle Dustin and I have been a licensed sales professional since 2021, prior to that I spent 10 years Active Duty in the United States Navy. My time in the NAVY cemented the core values of Honor, Courage and Commitment, which I always follow when I assist any families that are looking to protect their loved ones and their assets. My moto is that I would never process a policy that I would not trust my own family to be apart of, and I treat each one of my clients as if they are an extension of my family. I look forward to learning about your unique lifestyle and building an insurance plan that fits what your family needs!
Amber Stark
Licensed Sales Producer
Stephen Morrell
Licensed Sales Producer
David Rellinger
Licensed Sales Producer
Zachary Rogers
Licensed Sales Producer
Brandon Morrison
Licensed Sales Producer
I am a resident here in Jonesborough, Tn and started my career with the Gaudio Insurance Group in 2025. I am a licensed Property Insurance and Casualty Insurance as well as life and health. My primary focus within the agency is bringing in new customer and helping them determine the right coverage to protect their hard-earned assets.
Maleia Highfill
Licensed Sales Producer
I am Columbus area born and raised. With over 8 years of insurance sales experience, I have the ability to adapt to all walks of life! I enjoy passing my knowledge on to my clients for a relatable understanding of their insurance needs. When I am not working, I am a mother to 4 boys that keep me on my toes.
Eric Williams
Licensed Sales Producer
Janae Nunes
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
Tauseef Haider
Licensed Sales Producer
Alex Adams
Sr. Licensed Sales Producer
Jerri Purbaugh
Licensed Sales Producer
Ashley Fowler
Licensed Sales Producer
Cheryl Law
Licensed Sales Producer
Service
Kasie Huffman
Admin / New Business Support
I was born and raised in Heath, Ohio and still reside there. I have been working in insurance since April 2021. I do New Business insurance, update the agency website, make cancellation calls and collect payments. I am a mother to 3 boys. Before insurance I was a stay-at-home mom for 8 years. I look forward to meeting you and helping assist your business. Give us a call today.
Kayla Stalnaker
Admin / New Business Support
My name is Kayla Stalnaker and I live in dover, Ohio with my 2 dogs. I specialize in homeowners insurance, auto insurance and life insurance. In my free time I like to take my dogs for walks, tend to my plants, and crochet!
Atkins Delice
Admin / New Business Support
Alicia Cox
Admin / New Business Support
Tisha Howland
Customer Care Professional
I have 13 years of experience working in insurance. I currently hold licenses in Auto, Home, Life and Health. I am extremely service-oriented and enjoy exceeding the expectations of every member of the Gaudio Insurance Group family, that I have the pleasure of interacting with.
Melissa Guilliams
Customer Care Professional – Lead
I got my P&C license in June of 2019 and started working for the Gaudio Insurance Group in September of 2020. I focus on the many lines of Property & Casualty insurance such as Home Insurance /Auto Insurance/ Renters Insurance/ Personal Umbrellas/ Motorcycle Insurance/ ATV Insurance/ Boat Insurance and more.
I have been a resident of Coshocton my whole life, and proud to work for a great company in our little town.
Joseph Hamilton
Sr. Customer Care Professional
Christine Johns
Customer Care Professional
I have been doing insurance for five years now. I love what I do and am looking forward to continuing my career with a great company.
Stacey Tevis
Customer Care Professional- Lead
Hello, my name is Stacey. I started my insurance career in 2023. I am Property & Casualty Licensed, and joined Gaudio Insurance Group this year. I love helping others protect their greatest assets, and look forward to serving you!
Heather Russell
Customer Care Professional – Lead
Tina Huff
Sr. Customer Care Professional
I enjoy being a trusted advisor and help clients expose potential risks and making sure we cover any gaps. I also love to answer any questions on insurance to make it more understandable for all. When not working enjoy volunteering in my community and visiting seniors.
Danielle Sheeter
Customer Care Professional
Alberto Corona
Customer Care Professional
Kameron Wilson
Customer Care Professional – Lead
I currently reside in Wintersville, OH & I really enjoy assisting families with their insurance needs. I started my Insurance Career back in September of 2021 & hold licenses in multiple states. My primary focus here at the Gaudio Insurance Group is to provide & educate my customers with the knowledge of insurance based on their needs. I specialize in many lines of Property & Casualty Insurance including Auto, Home, Renter’s, Personal Liability, Boats, & many more! I am a mother of a 5-year-old daughter & I take pride in what I do to help customers protect what’s most important, family & assets!
Deishanaye Hall
Customer Care Professional
Kristen Journey
Customer Care Professional
My name is Kristen Journey. I am licensed in Property and Casualty insurance. I have been in the insurance industry for almost 5 years now. I started off in Sales and later transitioned to the Customer Service position. I am 27 years old and I have 2 kids and 2 puppies. I enjoy cooking and traveling for my leisure.
Jessica Rhome
Customer Care Professional
My name is Jessica, and I live in Ohio close by the famous Pro Football Hall of Fame. I am licensed in P&C along with life and health insurance. I have been working in the insurance industry for over a year and absolutely love it and getting to know the customers. In my free time, I love being with my family and doing anything outdoors. I am excited to be a part of the team and getting to know everyone!
Virginia Holt
Sr. Customer Care Professional
I began working in insurance in 2005. I truly love helping and serving people. I also enjoy getting to know all of the families I insure. I look forward to being here for you!
Robert Burd
Sr. Customer Care Professional
Jovannie Aguirre
Customer Care Professional
Kanedra Sanders
Customer Care Professional
As a Customer Service Professional at the Gaudio Insurance Group, I am dedicated to helping customers feel confident and supported every step of the way. With a strong focus on clear communication, problem-solving, and empathy, I strive to deliver reliable service and personalized solutions tailored to each individual’s needs. Whether you’re filing a claim, updating a policy, or just looking for guidance, I’m here to ensure you have a smooth and positive experience. You’re in good hands-and I’m proud to be part of the team that makes that promise real every day.
Jessica Moore
Customer Care Professional
I am a dedicated and enthusiastic insurance agent here. With a background in customer service, I specialize in P&C and Health insurance. I am here to provide personalized solutions to help clients protect what matters most.
Emma Smith
Customer Care Professional
Kelly Vargin
Customer Care Professional- Lead
Breann Conkle
Customer Care Professional
My name is Breann, and I live in Dover, Ohio with my husband and two kids. In the office I enjoy assisting with all your Auto Insurance and Homeowners Insurance needs. I have been in customer service ever since I started working. Assisting others has always been a big part of my life. In my spare time I am always with my family doing crafts, game nights, and anything that sounds fun.
Regina Domenick
Customer Care Professional
I am a resident of Canton, Ohio, I have lived here all my life. I have my license in property and casualty insurance and have been working in insurance for 6 years. But I am new to the Gaudio Insurance Group, and I am excited about getting to know all the customers and helping them with all their insurance needs. Before getting my license, I was a homemaker for 21 years, raised my three boys with my husband of 26 years. We enjoy going bowling, spending time outside and visiting with my boys.
Sharon Dragich
Customer Care Professional
Jolie Moore
Customer Care Professional
I have been a licensed agent going on for four years now. My goal is to help our customers have peace of mind.. Call or come to our agency today!
Tommea Clark
Customer Care Professional
Hello Insurance world my name is Tommea, but you can call me Mea I began working in insurance 5 years ago i started in service then transitioned over to sales for 3 years I have a insurance license in over 40 states I’ve sold cycle renters auto and jewelry but as of now I’m targeting the state of OHIO as the newest service agent on the team super excited to be a part of the GAUDIO INSURANCE GROUP
Chris Waller
Customer Care Professional
Steve Rocano
Customer Care Professional
Kathy Rodriguez
Customer Care Professional
Beth Sumor
Customer Care Professional
Oleg Faynshteyn
Customer Care Professional
Christina Pena Gonzalez
Customer Care Professional
I have been in the insurance industry for over a year assisting customers in both sales and customer service. I am licensed in Auto and home insurance.